Depicting Desire: Butch/Femme Representation in the Late 20th Century

A Senior Archives Capstone Collection by Sophie Jones '23

Menu

Skip to content
  • What is Butch/Femme?
  • Experiences + Reflections
  • Dyke TV / Oral Histories
  • Works Cited

Dyke TV / Oral Histories

Dorothy Allison and Carmen Vázquez

In this oral history conducted for the Voices of Feminism project in 2008, Dorothy Allison and Carmen Vázquez are interviewed by Kelly Anderson and reflect on their lives and various interactions with the feminist movement, the lesbian experience, and the butch/femme label. In the first clip, Allison describes how she came to discover her sexuality and some of her first sexual experiences with butches. In the second clip, Vázquez discusses presenting as masculine during her career at the San Francisco Department of Public Health. Both parties have agreed that this interview may be placed on the web.

Dyke TV

A favorite of many lesbians, Dyke TV was founded in 1993 as an offshoot of the activist group Lesbian Avengers. The program’s goal was to highlight LGBT issues, particularly those regarding lesbians. Through the visual representation of many different types of lesbians over the years that it was publicly broadcasted, many members of the community commented on the importance of representation – specifically for those historically underrepresented, such as masculine, butch, and trans lesbians. 

Episode #279 – 2002

Other Brothers” group in San Francisco discuss being black and identifying as masculine, transgender, and/or butch.

Episode #179 – 1997

Transgender and lesbian activist Leslie Feinberg reads a segment from her newly published book, Transgender Warriors, at A Different Light Bookstore.

Episode #166 – 1996

This “butch beer” commercial pokes fun at lesbian and butch stereotypes.

Episode #129 – 1995

Polly Thistlethwaite, AKA the “Butch Librarian” talks about LGBT books, their importance, and their historical omission from libraries.

Widgets

Personal Note: I arrived at Smith College confused. I knew it was the gay center of Massachusetts (after Provincetown, of course). I was excited to kiss a girl for the first time. But at night, I would stay up, swiping and swiping and swiping on men, seeking their validation even though there was little I found desirable about them romantically. Intro to Women and Gender Studies lead me to a Radicalesbians manifesto, the "Woman-Identified Woman," which taught me two things. The first was that I wanted to study archives. The second was how to end my quest for male approval - but the problem of attraction still remained.

I loved being friends with femmes. I loved doing their makeup, gossiping with them, and admiring their dresses and shoes from afar. But I didn't desire them. Senior year, after coming to a series of realizations, I was pointed to The Persistent Desire. After reading and learning about those before me, I realized that the joy of expressing femininity has never been for any man, that is has always been my own, and will always be just for me and the butches I present myself to.

I love masculine lesbians. I love how strong they are, how tender, how they take masculinity - a complicated and grand thing - and make it their own. I adore being friends with them and loving them. I want to defend them for the rest of my life, as a thank you for what they have done for me, all that they have shown me about love, about desire. Thank you, thank you, thank you.

Proudly powered by WordPress | Theme: Illustratr by WordPress.com.